Tall Buildings Policy, Nelson Mandela Bay (2018)

Two sketches: low buildings spread out along a road, and the same street lined with taller buildings and trees
Moving away from low-density sprawl to more compact corridors and nodes.

Between 2009 and 2018 noh ARCHITECTS, working with town planners Urban Dynamics, prepared a Tall Buildings Policy for the Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality. The brief asked for a uniform policy that sets out the Metro’s position on building height across its area, and that treats tallness as relative to its surroundings.

The need came from developers asking for departures that would allow buildings much taller than their neighbours, above all along the beachfront. Height is visible and emotive in a way that parking, coverage and density are not, and deciding each case on its own gave nobody certainty. At the same time the Metro wanted higher densities, because taller and more compact buildings make better use of existing infrastructure and slow the creep of suburbs into farmland and sensitive coastal areas.

The policy defines a tall building in relative terms: one that is at least 50% higher than the buildings within 100 metres of it, or taller than 20 metres where it affects the skyline, heritage resources or prominent vistas, or higher than eight storeys. Six policy statements set out when the Metro would support such buildings. They cover urban quality and design, alignment with local spatial plans, the capacity of services, access to public transport, and consultation.

Sketch of a tall building labelled top, shaft and plinth
Top, shaft and plinth.
Sketch of a city block with buildings placed along its street edges
Promoting the perimeter block.

The design guidelines divide a tall building into a plinth, a shaft and a top, with different rules for each. The plinth should run parallel to the street and form a continuous façade with its neighbours, so that the street works as an outdoor room. The shaft rises out of the plinth and is placed to limit shadow and wind at street level; the dominant wind in Nelson Mandela Bay comes from the south-west. The top must make a positive contribution to the skyline. Each guideline is tested against local buildings, with a plain yes or no on whether they meet it.

The policy proposes a two-step application. The first step tests whether a proposal aligns with the policy. Only then would the developer be invited to submit a design that responds to the guidelines.

The work went through a steering committee, working group meetings and public presentations, and through several drafts, the last of them dated April 2018.

Early studies for the policy tested how a height limit would sit on the Summerstrand beachfront.

Aerial view of Summerstrand at 2nd Avenue and Marine Drive with a red height envelope drawn over the beachfront buildings
An early height study from 2011: 2nd Avenue and Marine Drive, Summerstrand.
Panorama of the Summerstrand beachfront seen from the sea, from 2nd to 5th Avenue, with lines marking the permitted height
The same study seen from the sea: the Summerstrand beachfront from 2nd to 5th Avenue.